After acquiring a clutch kit from Autozone, O'Riely (AP pressure plate with Valeo disk) and AutohausAZ (Sachs) I decided to go with the Sachs pressure plate and disk and returned the other two.
Here's the Sachs and Valeo disks side by side. The Sachs disk is like the original disk I removed which has the extra "layer" of small springs. I'm not sure how important that is and I'm sure the Valeo disk would have worked.
Thickness compared to original Sachs disk: